EFF, TEDIC, and CEJIL File Complaint Over Paraguay’s Secretive Use of Facial Recognition
EFF, TEDIC, and CEJIL have petitioned the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights to challenge Paraguay's refusal to disclose details regarding its facial recognition surveillance systems.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), the Association of Technology, Education, Development, Research, Communication (TEDIC), and the Centre for Justice and International Law (CEJIL) have filed a formal complaint with the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. According to the EFF, the petition targets the Paraguayan state for arbitrarily denying access to information regarding its implementation of facial recognition as a tool for mass surveillance. The legal action follows years of opacity surrounding surveillance cameras installed by the Ministry of the Interior and National Police in Asunción in 2019.
The dispute began when TEDIC executive director Maricarmen Sequera filed an information request seeking protocols for the processing of personal data and details on the system's implementation. According to the EFF, the request specifically asked whether the state had conducted human rights or data protection impact assessments. The ministry denied the majority of the request, asserting that implementation details and personal data processing protocols constituted confidential security information. Although TEDIC contested this secrecy in domestic courts, the EFF reports that judicial analyses lagged and ultimately upheld the government's denial.
The petition filed last Friday (19) argues that Paraguayan authorities disregarded Inter-American standards that uphold the public's right to access information, even in matters related to national security. The coalition contends that the refusal to provide information violates the right to informational self-determination and privacy. By bringing the case to the Commission, the organizations aim to establish that the state cannot use security as a blanket justification to bypass transparency requirements when deploying intrusive biometric technologies.
The coalition is asking the Commission to recognize these rights violations and compel the state to deliver the specific information originally requested by TEDIC. Furthermore, the petition seeks an order requiring Paraguay to adopt permanent mechanisms of active transparency. These mechanisms would cover the acquisition, contracting, financing, and functioning of any surveillance technologies used by public bodies, particularly those involving artificial intelligence or the processing of biometric data, according to the EFF report.
Beyond transparency, the legal challenge seeks to mandate human rights impact assessments prior to the acquisition of any new surveillance technology. The EFF notes that the Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Expression has emphasized that states must acknowledge surveillance capabilities at a meaningful level of detail to facilitate public debate. The coalition argues that the lack of transparency in Paraguay is not an isolated incident but reflects a broader trend of normalization of intrusive surveillance across Latin America, where opacity in security matters remains the rule.