EU Kids Act Mandates Systemic Age Verification and Threatens User Privacy
The European Commission's draft EU Kids Act introduces systemic age verification and access rules that privacy advocates warn will threaten digital privacy and civil liberties.
The European Commission has presented a draft law aimed at restricting young people's access to the internet, according to EFF Deeplinks. The legislation, known as the EU Kids Act, seeks to protect children from risks associated with social media, video games, and AI systems by introducing age-based access rules, safety requirements, and enforcement measures. The publication notes that the proposal builds upon the Digital Services Act and translates some of its non-binding guidelines into hard law.
According to EFF Deeplinks, the proposal is structured around social media age delays, safety by design, age assurance, parental responsibility, and strong enforcement. Following expert advice, the framework creates phased access to platforms that rely on personalized recommender systems or uninterrupted content consumption. Children under 13 would have no service accounts, users aged 13 to 15 would face restricted accounts under parental supervision, and those 15 to 18 would access autonomous accounts in safe-by-design environments. Full access is reserved for adults.
The publication emphasizes that age gates undermine civil liberties, reduce safety, and create barriers to internet entry, particularly for marginalized groups. This access delay is paired with privacy-intrusive age verification relying on an EU scheme. For teenagers, the law places significant control in the hands of parents, who must set up accounts and prove their parental status. While a French court recently declared undifferentiated social media bans unconstitutional, the Kids Act distinguishes between age groups and uses a risk-based approach, exempting verification if providers are confident users are adults.
Despite these distinctions, the proposal broadly covers social media and video-sharing services, using age thresholds that EFF Deeplinks describes as a blunt proxy for maturity. The publication points out that the regulation pays little attention to user privacy, freedom of expression, and children's rights to access information. Furthermore, the legislation creates an infrastructure for control and entrenches the power of big tech companies.
The proposal provides exemptions for not-for-profit encyclopedias, scientific repositories, educational services, and open-source software-developing platforms, according to EFF Deeplinks. However, it offers no exceptions for small and medium-sized enterprises, which the publication states will foster the dominance of resource-laden tech companies. Companies are expected to utilize privacy-unfriendly age checks across their platforms to mitigate liability.
The legislation's safety-by-design pillar applies to social media, video-sharing, online games, AI companions, chatbots, and app stores. Providers must make child-safe design the default unless they use age assurance to establish that a user is an adult, as reported by EFF Deeplinks. Rules target addictive features like infinite scrolling and require chatbots to reduce minors' exposure to emotional dependencies, while app stores act as gatekeepers for age-appropriate access.
EFF Deeplinks highlights that the Kids Act has not undergone a full impact assessment process, which normally entails checking alternative policy options and consulting stakeholders. The publication concludes by calling on European Union lawmakers to modify the most harmful suggestions to protect the fundamental rights of all users.
Sources
- 01 EU Kids Act Won't Keep the Internet Accountable and Trustworthy — EFF Deeplinks