Supreme Court Limits Government Use of Geofence Warrants, Upholds Location Data Privacy
The Supreme Court ruled in Chatrie v. United States that individuals maintain a Fourth Amendment expectation of privacy in their location data, requiring law enforcement to obtain a warrant for geofence searches.
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Chatrie v. United States that individuals possess a constitutional expectation of privacy in their location data, establishing that even short-term surveillance of physical movements constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment. According to Ars Technica, the 6-3 decision rejected the government’s argument that location data collected by third parties—such as Google—was too minimal to warrant protection. Writing for the majority, Justice Elena Kagan stated that "an individual has a reasonable expectation of privacy in records about his cell phone’s location, and police intrude on that constitutionally protected interest when they demand the information."
The case originated from the investigation of Okello Chatrie, an armed bank robber. Law enforcement utilized a geofence warrant, which compelled Google to provide data on every device located within a specific radius of a crime scene in Northern Virginia. As reported by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), these warrants act as "dragnet surveillance," effectively turning innocent bystanders into potential suspects. The government had argued that Chatrie lacked a privacy expectation because he voluntarily shared his location with Google, and that the data merely reflected his movements in public spaces. The Court dismissed these claims, emphasizing that carrying a smartphone is an essential aspect of modern life.
Justice Kagan’s opinion addressed the reality of modern technology, noting that Google frequently prompts users to enable location services, often without disclosing how frequently or precisely that data is recorded or shared with law enforcement. The Court held that users do not forfeit their privacy rights simply by engaging in the "ordinary things cell-phone users do." Furthermore, the ruling expanded upon the 2018 Carpenter v. United States decision. While Carpenter dealt with prolonged tracking, the Chatrie decision confirmed that shorter-term surveillance is also a search because it can reveal "a wealth of detail about a person’s familial, political, professional, religious, and sexual associations," according to Justice Sonia Sotomayor.
In his dissent, Justice Samuel Alito argued that the majority’s decision would create "upheaval" in Fourth Amendment law by mandating a warrant for any access to third-party cell-phone location information, regardless of the duration or nature of the request. He suggested that the Court should have adopted an app-by-app approach to evaluating privacy expectations. However, the majority rejected this, with Justice Kagan writing that "the point of carrying smartphones is to use what is on them," and that the government’s proposed approach would disconnect the act of carrying a phone from the privacy protections afforded to the data it generates.
The Supreme Court did not declare geofence warrants inherently unconstitutional, but the ruling forces law enforcement to establish probable cause to access such data. The case now returns to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit. The Supreme Court remanded the matter to determine whether the specific warrant used in the Chatrie investigation was reasonable under the Fourth Amendment, or if the "good faith" doctrine applies. As noted by the EFF, while Google has already implemented changes to its data storage that effectively prevent the company from responding to mass geofence searches, the Chatrie decision provides a critical precedent for future challenges regarding digital privacy.
Sources
- 01 Victory! Supreme Court Says Constitution Protects People’s Location Data — EFF Deeplinks
- 02 Supreme Court ruling guts government’s use of geofence warrants — Ars Technica — Policy